Download No Sure Victory: Measuring U.S. Army Effectiveness and by Gregory A. Daddis PDF

By Gregory A. Daddis

Traditional knowledge holds that the USA military in Vietnam, thrust into an unconventional conflict the place occupying terrain used to be a meaningless degree of luck, relied on physique counts as its sole degree of army growth. In No certain Victory, military officer and historian Gregory Daddis seems some distance deeper into the Army's ideas for measuring army good fortune and offers a way more complicated-and disturbing-account of the yank misadventure in Indochina.

Daddis exhibits how the united states military, which faced an unusual enemy and an excellent extra unusual kind of battle, followed an immense, and at last unmanageable, process of measurements and formulation to trace the growth of army operations that ranged from pacification efforts to search-and-destroy missions. The Army's per month ''Measurement of Progress'' stories coated innumerable elements of the combating in Vietnam-force ratios, Vietcong/North Vietnamese military incidents, tactical air sorties, guns losses, safety of base components and roads, inhabitants keep watch over, sector keep watch over, and hamlet defenses. Concentrating extra on info assortment and not more on facts research, those indiscriminate makes an attempt to gauge luck may very well have hindered the army's skill to judge the genuine consequence of the struggle at hand--a roadblock that Daddis believes considerably contributed to the various mess ups that American forces suffered in Vietnam.

Filled with incisive research and wealthy old element, No definite Victory isn't just a helpful case learn in unconventional war, yet a cautionary story that provides vital views on easy methods to degree functionality in present and destiny armed clash. Given America's ongoing counterinsurgency efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan, No definite Victory presents precious old viewpoint on the best way to measure--and mismeasure--military luck

Show description

Read or Download No Sure Victory: Measuring U.S. Army Effectiveness and Progress in the Vietnam War PDF

Best security books

Imaging for Forensics and Security: From Theory to Practice (Signals and Communication Technology)

Imaging for Forensics and safety: From idea to perform presents a close research of recent imaging and development popularity suggestions for the certainty and deployment of biometrics and forensic ideas. those concepts can be utilized for sensible ideas to extend defense. the fabric features a number of the new advances within the know-how starting from conception, layout, and implementation to functionality review of biometric and forensic structures.


E-book by means of

Mutation breeding in chickpea : perspectives and prospects for food security

Examine on brought on mutagenesis of pulses together with chickpea is much less universal in comparison to the only on cereals and henceforth the current paintings is pioneering within the box. The chickpea is likely one of the greatest grown pulse vegetation in India. the writer hopes that his e-book might help to improve reviews on pulses, and within the long term, to lessen foodstuff lack of confidence and malnutrition persisting in numerous constructing international locations

Additional info for No Sure Victory: Measuring U.S. Army Effectiveness and Progress in the Vietnam War

Example text

How could a division commander devise and offer a “better idea” once he was deployed to Southeast Asia and engaged in combat operations? Once occupied in searching for and destroying enemy units, there often seemed little incentive to devote time and resources away from actual fighting. American officers largely dismissed British and French experiences for their seeming irrelevance to tactical combat operations in Vietnam. S. officers came across few suggestions for measuring success in counterinsurgencies.

37 This mosaic nature, which many American senior officers seemed to have overlooked, made assessing army progress in Vietnam all the more daunting. So too did the nature of the American military experience in Southeast Asia. S. Army policies for the rotation of personnel did little to promote either transmission of lessons or thoughtful analysis of unit effectiveness. ”38 The validity of these statistics often depended entirely upon the reporting commander. With tours of duty rarely extending beyond one year, a commander’s perceptions could be a significant variable in determining organizational effectiveness.

S. Army’s ranks in the early 1970s altered how senior officers wrestled with measuring success. Limits of the Study Counterinsurgencies are complex affairs. Former advisor Dave R. S. Army experience during the Vietnam War. S. Army’s ability to achieve its objectives. However, these areas will be considered only to the extent that they shaped the army’s perceptions of its own progress and effectiveness. As an example, this study will not evaluate air power effectiveness in Vietnam. S. Army combat units were not the only American forces operating in South Vietnam.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.91 of 5 – based on 17 votes

Author: admin